Manhattan Exclusive Halloween Costume Celebration
Morgan sighed as he walked up the steps to his apartment building. Already, the city was alive with the buzz of Halloween energy. People in costumes chattered and laughed, off to some fun gathering or party.
But not Morgan. Not this year, at least.
His friend group had unceremoniously excommunicated him when his four-year relationship with one of the other members fell apart. Morgan thought Abbie would someday be his wife, but it turned out they wanted different things. At the time, he saw it as the most mature breakup of his life, a series of deep, honest conversations that led them to the decision to end the relationship.
Apparently that’s not how Abbie told the story, and suddenly he was a pariah, kicked from the friend group without so much as the courtesy of any of them hearing his side of the story.
It was hard to keep the self-pity at bay as he climbed the stairs. Halloween was his favorite holiday, and he had so many great memories of dressing up and going out. He always looked forward to it. But the only thing he had to look forward to tonight was some crappy TV dinner and rewatching a show on streaming he’d seen a hundred times already.
A glint of light on his apartment door caught his eye. Dread bubbled up inside. In his experience, something taped to your apartment door in New York City was always a bad sign. Rent was going up, bed bugs had been discovered in the building, the property had been sold, and all tenants had 30 days to vacate; he’d seen it all in the twelve years since he moved here.
But this was different. Fancy, metallic lettering on thick, black paper. He turned it over in his hand as he unlocked the door, then flicked on the light to see it better.
You’re Invited
Manhattan Exclusive Halloween Costume Celebration
Only 500 Guests!
The writing was embossed, and he slid his fingertip across it. He’d never heard of the Manhattan Exclusive Halloween Costume Celebration before, but whoever ran it shelled out some serious bucks on the invitations. The question was, who on earth would invite him to something like this?
Morgan opened his door and poked his head into the hallway. Was there a kindly neighbor who’d noticed he’d been spending all of his time alone lately? His building wasn’t exactly nice; it was hard to imagine anyone who called it home possessing the money or connections to have an extra invitation lying around for an exclusive Manhattan party. Then again, he’d learned not to judge people too quickly. He’d judged Abbie to be a trustworthy, good person, and he saw where that got him.
Going back inside, Morgan laid the invitation on the counter and considered it. It was already after 6:30, and the party started at 7. It’d be tight, but if he left now, he figured he could make it.
Turning on his bedroom light, Morgan looked through his tiny closet. He was on the stage crew at Ravnith Theater, an off-off-off Broadway theater that collected has-beens and never-were who couldn’t hack it in the real world of stage and film. As one of those never-were, Morgan was grateful for the job. It was nice to be a part of the industry he’d grown up loving, even if he was just barely on the fringes.
It also afforded him a closet that contained a few costumes. From time to time, the stage crew played extras, and he’d snatched a favorite costume or two in his time. Flipping through them, he frowned. None lived up to the usual over-the-top affair he’d put together for Halloween.
He hesitated at a set of western gear. Going as a cowboy wouldn’t turn any heads, but it should be enough to get him through the door. The problem was finding all the accessories. His jeans were wadded up somewhere in the corner, and he couldn’t remember if he’d even brought home the cowboy hat that went with the costume. By the time he put it all together, he’d be late.
And so he settled on the next costume in his closet. Cult member. It was a flowing, dark purple robe, the look brought together by the attached hood. Even less head-turning than a cowboy, but he could throw it on over his clothes and be out the door in less than a minute.
Three minutes later, he was racing for the subway, a purple-robed cultist surrounded by vampires, ghosts, nurses both sexy and un-sexy, countless movie and pop culture characters, and the usual mass of New Yorkers who looked as New Yorker and unbothered as always, just going about their business like a bunch of costumed people weren’t among them.
As he reached his destination, he saw what he’d expected. Manhattan was packed. Morgan tried to be respectful as he pushed through the crowd. The fancy invitation was folded in his pocket under his robe, a reminder that an event this nice probably started on time.
He fished out his phone and glanced at it as he waited for the traffic signal to change. 6:58, and he was close. The building was on the next block. He was going to make it.
The light changed, and he crossed with the throng of people, then broke into a jog. He saw the building ahead. It was just as fancy as the invitation, and for the first time he wondered whether he'd fit in with the kind of people who came to something like this. Was this a one percenter thing, where everyone talked about their vacation homes and stock dividends?
“You! We’re down here!”
He paused as he crossed an alley. It sure sounded like whoever was yelling was talking to him. Turning, he saw them, head sticking out of a side door that led into the building. They wore a costume similar to his own.
“Uh, sorry? I think you might be-”
“Manhattan Exclusive Halloween Costume Celebration?” the woman yelled.
Morgan walked a few steps into the alley.
“Oh, uh, yeah.”
She waved him forward.
“Get in here, then.”
He jogged forward, slightly confused. Why wouldn’t they just use the front door?
The woman stepped into the open, holding the door open for him. Morgan shook his head and smiled under his hood. It was uncanny how similar their costumes were.
“What are the chances that-”
“You’re late,” she snapped.
“Am I? It’s not even-”
“If you’re not early, you’re late. Get inside!”
He sped up and went inside, confused. Was the lady upset that their costumes were so similar?
She put her hand on his back and pushed him.
“Pick it up, they’re holding the elevator for us.”
“They?” Morgan muttered.
Prickles of annoyance rose inside him, but this was better than spending another evening being sad on the couch all alone. At least he was socializing.
They reached the end of the hall, and Morgan slowed to a stop. The elevator was packed, twelve people, by his count.
They all wore purple cult robes.
“Wait, what is going-”
“In!” the woman said, shoving him into the elevator.
Morgan crashed into the tightly pressed bodies, drawing groans and mutters. He regained his balance and tried to tuck himself into the back corner.
It was difficult to fathom how all of them had ended up in the same costume. If not for slight differences between his robe and theirs, he’d assume they’d all come from his theater. But their robes seemed higher quality and had a few artistic touches along the shoulder.
However they’d all come to be wearing the same costume, none of them seemed particularly enthused to be heading up to the party. Everyone in the elevator was tense, eyes either on the floor or darting around nervously. It didn’t help that it was blazing hot in the enclosed space.
The woman who herded him onto the elevator stepped on and pressed the button for the top floor. Once the doors closed, she turned to address everyone.
“Any first-timers? Raise your hands so I can see you.”
Morgan raised his hand, as did two others.
“Listen closely,” she said. “It’s going to get chaotic in there, but focus on your task, and you’ll be fine. We’re going to meet up with the others and form a circle around the room. Then you’ll lock arms and slowly close in on the center of the room. No one gets out of that circle, understand? I don’t care what you have to do. Kick, punch, bite, you keep them in the circle, and force them to the center.”
A touch of panic mixed with his confusion. Was this some sort of a role-playing thing? Maybe he missed some of the details on the invitation?
As the elevator climbed ever higher, the woman stared hard at the collection of cultists. The tense atmosphere shifted to one of dread, and a heavy knot formed in Morgan’s stomach.
“Now for the important part. The don’ts. Don’t speak, and whatever you do, don’t expose your face. If the entity identifies you by sight or sound, you’ll be consumed on the spot.”
At least ten pressing questions popped into his mind. Chief among them, what did she mean by “the entity”?
“Just as important. Don’t try to run away. My associates are posted at every possible exit, and they will not hesitate to put a bullet in your brain if they even think you’re trying to abandon your duty.” She swept her hard eyes over them. “The time to back out has passed. Do your duty, and the money will be in your accounts by the time you get home tonight.”
His stomach rumbled, and his heart pounded in his chest. The polyester robe stuck to his sweat-slicked skin, adding to his growing claustrophobia. He pulled at it, trying to get a full breath and trying to keep from throwing up. Was this lady for real?
The elevator doors opened, and the cultists jogged out. Morgan was swept along with them. Music boomed nearby, the bass shaking the floor.
Morgan’s eyes darted all around, searching for somewhere to hide or a hallway he could flee down. Men in suits were posted all around, their bulging muscles hard to miss despite the formal wear. They each wore a small earpiece, and he was pretty sure he could make out the shape of a gun under their jackets.
The only path not blocked was the entrance into the grand ballroom, and so he continued that direction with all the others. The space was massive, offering the best view he’d ever seen in the city. The area was all windows and open space, giving everyone inside a bird’s-eye view of Manhattan. A large DJ booth sat in the center of the dance floor, and hundreds of party-goers already packed the place.
More cultists poured in from other entrances, and soon they formed a huge ring around the room's edge. The few party-goers who noticed them paid them no mind, hoisting drinks, smiling, and laughing, swaying to music without a care in the world.
A cultist on his left hooked their arm through his, and someone on his right did the same. Morgan tried to pull away, but they held tight, keeping him in place.
Something shifted on the dance floor. It was hard to see details through the throng of people, but he didn’t need to see. He could feel the change. Everyone sensed it. The dancing stopped, and the conversations died. From below the DJ booth, something emerged.
The entity.
Before the room fell into chaos, Morgan caught a single glimpse of it. Smaller than he would’ve assumed, a being of smoke and teeth. Darkness pulsed from it, and everyone screamed. The music cut off, and the feast began.
Confusion took hold, and no one seemed certain what to do. That made it easy to herd them toward the entity. Morgan didn’t want to be here, and he certainly didn’t want to hurt anyone. But he was as much at the mercy of the cultists as the party-goers were, being dragged forward as they closed the circle, shoving people into the center of the room.
Into the waiting maw of the entity.
A group of five people fell into its mouth, and a moment later a geyser of blood erupted from it. Pieces of bone and costume were mixed in with the blood, and the gory mixture rained down. People slipped and fell as they tried to run, making it easier for the entity to drag them closer with its smoky tendrils.
Forget the don’ts, Morgan couldn’t be a part of this. He tore his arms away from the neighboring cultists and turned toward the exit. Another cultist had the same idea moments before and was already sprinting for the exit. The men in suits were waiting there, guns drawn, and two of them fired. The cultist’s body jerked and shimmied, then collapsed.
One of the men shifted his aim, bringing his pistol to bear on Morgan. So he did the only thing he could, and spun around and hooked his arms back with his neighboring cultists. Every muscle in his body tensed, waiting for the bullet that never came.
Morgan cried as they surged forward, blocking those who tried to flee. A woman dressed as a wizard ran straight at him, her face twisted into a mask of fear. Driven by the terror of the gunmen at his back, he gritted his teeth and kicked the woman in the chest. She cried out as she stumbled backward, off balance, right into the entity's waiting arms. It tore her in two and held her body above itself, bathing in the blood.
Nearly everyone in the place was dead. Blood dripped from the ceilings and covered the floor. It stung his eyes and blurred his vision, mixing with his tears.
But the entity was not satisfied.
It surged forth, falling upon a group of the cultists and devouring them.
“Disperse!” someone yelled.
This time, everyone ran. The gunmen abandoned their post, fleeing like all the rest. Screams and horrific tearing and squelching sounds filled his ears, but Morgan dared not look behind him as he ran. Body parts and buckets of blood pelted him from behind, and the stink of death filled his nostrils.
He crashed off of people, bouncing from one to the next. The entity was near, coming for them all. His feet got tangled with the person running next to him. Somehow, Morgan stayed upright, but the other cultist wasn’t so lucky. They were dead before they hit the ground, another tasty morsel for the entity to enjoy.
Morgan saw a door to his left and threw himself into it. It swung open, and he stumbled through, out into the stairwell. He went headlong down the steps, toppling and hitting hard on his side. He tumbled down, taking two hard impacts, first on his side, then on his lower back, before somersaulting to a stop at the first landing.
He lay there a moment and sobbed. But then he heard more screaming, and he forced the pain away. There could be no rest, not while the entity was still nearby.
The escape down the stairwell seemed an endless hell. He couldn’t breathe, and sweat poured out of him, soaking through his costume. The muscles in his sides repeatedly cramped, and his legs felt like jelly. Only sheer terror and dread kept him upright and moving.
When he reached the ground floor, he exploded through the exit door and collapsed onto his face in the dark alley. He puked, the foul discharge filling the hood of his costume. He rolled onto his side and peeled the robe from his body, feeling like he could finally breathe once it was off. The walls rejected his sobs and cries, echoing them back at him, a reminder of the horror he’d just experienced.
It took all that remained in him to get back to his feet and stumble out onto the sidewalk. He moved on instinct, driven by the deep need to be away from wherever the entity was. His vision was awash with tears, a blurry mess, and he didn’t bother to apologize to the many people he bumped into as he made his way toward the subway station. Tremors seized his entire body, and he couldn’t stop his teeth from chattering.
It took him several tries to get his debit card out of his wallet to pay for the subway. He stumbled down the stairs, legs threatening to give out. After all that hard work to survive, it felt like death was still less than a breath away. He imagined himself having a heart attack and pitching forward onto the tracks, imagined the wheels of the subway car slicing him into pieces as they ran him over.
But somehow he stayed upright, and when the train arrived, he shuffled onto it and collapsed into a seat. He could still hear the screams. The look on the woman’s face, the one he had kicked, filled his vision. There was something in her eyes in that last second before she’d been torn apart. A question.
Why?
“That’s sick, bro.”
Morgan looked up, surprised to see a man standing right in front of him. He wore some sort of man-turtle costume, and his glassy red eyes suggested he’d been having a good time this Halloween night.
“Huh?” Morgan asked.
The man pointed at his face.
“All the fake blood. Sick costume.”
Morgan wiped his face, then checked his hand. It was covered in blood, and the fullness of the night’s events crashed down on him, ripping through him like the phantom bullet he’d feared earlier in the night that had never come. He screamed and sobbed and screamed some more.
And the good people of New York paid him no mind, thinking him just another crazy person, someone who’d lost themselves to some disease or circumstance.
It was a fair conclusion.
October 26, 2026
MOTIVATION MONDAY - SUBJECT #95 OF 104